While many spent the holiday season with friends and family, at least dozens of people in El Salvador were also dedicating a good chunk of time to chasing down customer support for their government-provided bitcoin wallets — and posting about it on Twitter.
Sometime between November and December, the website began to fill up with noticeably more complaints about unknown or failed transactions related to Chivo, the state-backed bitcoin wallet that went live in September to much fanfare.
“I’ve spent almost two months waiting for them to help me with a transaction of almost $1,000 at the time,” Twitter user @Josh_91_L posted on December 9. “Now with the value of BTC plummeting and continuing like this, it seems like it will be much less. I’m still hoping that one day they can resolve it, willingly.”
“Yesterday, I found out transactions in my bank account have been made through the Chivo Wallet that add up to an amount over $3,000,” Twitter user Jenn_Larin85 wrote on Dec. 19. “Hoping that they [solve this for me] as soon as possible!”
Chivo, which is local slang for “cool,” has played a starring role in the drama that has been ongoing since El Salvador enacted a law in September making Bitcoin legal tender. The wallet, which is optional to use and supports both Bitcoin and the local currency of U.S. dollars, is designed to offer a few perks just for Salvadorans.
In addition to getting a free $30 in Bitcoin when signing up, Chivo users pay no commission for remittances to other users of the app, currency conversions or taking physical cash out of the 200 Chivo-branded ATMs around the country.
When Chivo works the way it’s supposed to, these features have made it easier for Salvadorans to send remittances and pay for things without needing physical cash. However, many users say a host of issues have shaken their confidence in the app.
Over the past month, The Block has reviewed a range of complaints about Chivo on social media, including claims of unauthorized charges in the app and external bank accounts, blocked accounts, phishing schemes targeting users, failed transfers to other wallets and identity theft. In addition, more than 10 people shared their firsthand accounts of issues for this article.
While The Block couldn’t independently verify all of the social media posts complaining about Chivo, our reporting unearthed evidence that in its short life, the app has experienced several types of problems that have affected a significant number of people.
And yet, The Block was unable to obtain clear responses or comments explaining these issues from either government officials or representatives of the private companies that helped El Salvador develop Chivo.
Disappearing funds, failed transfers and blocked accounts
Chivo was never a perfect app. It became clear from day one that the initial iteration of the wallet was dogged by technical glitches and bugs. But recent reports from Chivo users on social media show that the software continues to have issues — not only that affect the app’s user experience, but in some cases, the amounts of money in people’s accounts.
One of the reasons for the increased visibility of Chivo’s issues in recent weeks is that some Salvadorans have taken it upon themselves to publicly track complaints about the wallet.
The most high-profile of these efforts is a now-infamous Dec. 18 thread by an anonymous Twitter user named El Comisionado, or “The Commissioner” in English. It began with 50 instances of people claiming that they had lost funds in Chivo or their bank accounts, or that they couldn’t access them in the app. The thread has since grown to 80 individual reports, representing more than $127,000 in allegedly stolen, inaccessible or unrealized funds. Most of these claims are reflected here.
The issues raised in the thread tend to center on a few main themes: people claiming they’ve been blocked from entering their Chivo accounts, unauthorized Chivo-related charges, failed or pending transactions and problems with Chivo ATMs.
Multiple people told The Block that they have called the Chivo helpline numerous times and heard that a tech support team will call them back or send an email about their case. However, they are still waiting for final resolution weeks or even months later.
It is not known exactly how many people have had these kinds of problems with the Chivo app, how many cases have been resolved nor the total amount of funds affected. El Comisionado told The Block that they did not include small transactions of $50 or less in the thread, or reports that did not mention an amount.
What we do know is that people from different walks of life have reported issues with Chivo, from those who never wanted anything to do with the wallet all the way to crypto enthusiasts and supporters of President Nayib Bukele, who spearheaded the Bitcoin law. The problems have affected both people in El Salvador as well as those living abroad.
Some have been able to get their money back or cases resolved after contacting customer service. For example, a Twitter user named Gaby Rodriguez-Trippconey reported that someone had taken $3,921 from her bank account after making 13 fraudulent transactions in the name of Chivo, but then said the issue was resolved after investigations by Chivo as well as her bank.
Others are still waiting, including Eliezer Hernandez Arias, one of several people who told The Block that they weren’t able to access Chivo due to their account being blocked. Hernandez says he hasn’t been able to access his Chivo account since November 3, with the exception of a few days following an app update in December when he could log in but not access his funds.
Hernandez said he was using Chivo to trade crypto without a commission, and that most of his friends in a 29-person Telegram group — who have also used the app for trading and scalping — have the same problem.
“I’ve tried everything. I’ve gone to the Chivo Points, I have called the call center every week since I’ve been blocked, I’ve gone to the prosecutor’s office and they haven’t given me a solution,” he said. “They only say my case is in the compliance department, and that they can’t give me more information.”
Since Hernandez holds a sizable amount of Bitcoin in Chivo Wallet he can’t access, he’s still trying to solve the problem. Over the past few weeks, he and his friends have noticed that the text of the error messages showing up when they try to access Chivo has changed. First, the messages said that the user or password is incorrect. Then, they noticed different errors, like that the telephone number is invalid or that the user needs to use a real telephone number to register.
The Block has separately viewed other examples of blocked or inaccessible accounts from other users. One showed a completely blank screen and another read in Spanish: “Failed verification — soon your account will be updated. Your registration will be reviewed by our support team.”
It’s unclear whether Chivo is blocking people for certain types of trading activity, identity verification issues or something else.
Chivo did acknowledge in October that it had eliminated the ability for users to see a frozen Bitcoin price for up to a minute before trading. This had allowed people to check other exchanges in the meantime and perform speculative trading like scalping while that price was fixed (scalping is legal, but Chivo said it would be a type of fraud in this case due to the frozen prices).
Several people have also reported that they were unable to transfer funds between Chivo and other crypto wallets. Twitter user Balmory Parada posted on January 7 that he and his wife transferred $1,000 from Chivo to their Strike accounts via the Lightning Network, but two weeks later the transaction was still pending with the funds unavailable.
While it’s possible some of these issues could have to do with other wallets, the sheer number of reports about failed or pending crypto transactions involving Chivo users raises questions about the app’s role. Another Chivo user, who asked that their name not be published due to fear over potential retribution for speaking out, told The Block that they tried to transfer $64.33 from Chivo to their Exodus crypto wallet on December 16. They said the transaction is still pending after at least 15 calls to Chivo’s customer service line, with the money still unavailable for use in Chivo.
Chivo is inconsistent
To explore the app first hand, I attempted to make several transfers to two different individuals’ Chivo accounts. The experiences couldn’t have been any more different.
First, I tried to send Bitcoin to a crypto-savvy Salvadoran named José under the condition that he return the funds immediately after receiving them. But according to Chivo, the funds never showed up in his wallet.
I had used Wallet of Satoshi to send two Lightning Network transactions for 24 sats and 1,193 sats to his Chivo wallet. But shortly after, he sent me a screenshot showing the transfers as “canceled” in Chivo, despite my receiving confirmations showing the transactions as paid.
Then, I used my Coinbase wallet to send an on-chain Bitcoin transaction worth $4.25. Screenshots show that this transaction was also marked as “canceled” in Chivo, even though a Bitcoin block explorer showed that it had been confirmed. That means José’s wallet had indeed received my funds, but Chivo’s interface for some reason didn’t reflect the transaction.
Next, I tried to send money to my friend Mario and the transaction worked perfectly. He quickly received both the Lightning and on-chain Bitcoin transactions and sent them back to my wallets without issue.
So yes, Chivo does work — just not all the time.
Shouting into the void
Among the people who spoke with The Block about Chivo, one of the biggest complaints was that someone else had used their personal information to create accounts in their name or those of family members.
To open a Chivo account, a person needs an El Salvador ID number and a valid phone number. The app then asks for a photo of the ID and a selfie for facial recognition. Many Salvadorans have provided this information if only to get the free Bitcoin.
But this verification system may not be foolproof. CoinDesk reported back in October that some people have shown how they achieved verification — and therefore unlocked the $30 bonus — by apparently taking a photo of an ID photocopy instead of a physical one, and snapping a “selfie” of a coffee mug or movie poster character instead of their actual face.
Whatever the reason, there are plenty of reports of people finding out they already had active Chivo accounts despite not having ever used the app.
Marisol, a marketing manager, told The Block that she had no interest in using the app, and so was surprised to find out upon downloading it that she already had an account. She contacted Chivo, and someone called her back to confirm an account had been set up using her personal information. Chivo ended up resetting the account and mentioned there had been a transaction. But she still doesn’t know who created it and had been hoping to find out so she could file a legal complaint.
Ruth López, lawyer and legal chief of anti-corruption and justice at the human rights organization Cristosal, told The Block that the organization opened a special online platform to collect complaints about Chivo between October 9 and October 14 and again between November 5 and November 7. About 1,200 people wrote in, with the majority of complaints having to do with their credentials being used by someone else without their consent to make or use Chivo accounts.
López, who was herself was a victim of someone using her personal details to open a Chivo account, said Cristosal decided to open the commenting platform after noticing many complaints on social media and no word from the government.
“People who are public employees, for example, contacted me directly through my personal Twitter account telling me: ‘Look, I wrote but I can’t present myself because I can’t take the risk, come out on a list and lose my job,’” López said.
According to López, many people are not even worried about the $30 as much as someone using their personal data to commit crimes that will later be traced back to them.
Despite these legitimate fears, “there was no institutional response,” said López. “There were many complaints and no public institution was doing anything.”
Cristosal has also launched two different types of legal actions related to Chivo that involve more than 200 individuals each but says the government has not acknowledged those either. “Public institutions are totally silent,” López said.
This official silence has left the kind of void that social media scambots are made to exploit. As people look for closure to solve their Chivo problems on social media, Twitter bots posing as official Chivo customer support accounts and individual agents respond immediately to almost any post mentioning the name of the wallet, asking for many of the same details that the real accounts do.
When I tweeted anything with the word “Chivo” in it, bots with names translating to things like “Chivo Wallet Support” and “Chivo Support” would regularly be the first to respond. The typical post was a kind offer to help followed by a suspicious link. Because these fake accounts generally set their profile picture with the blue-and-white Chivo logo, it’s clear to see how some people might be confused.
And yet, there seems to be very little — if any — official warning from Chivo or the government about these scams and how to protect oneself. Meanwhile, the official, Twitter-verified Chivo account’s communication strategy is inconsistent, furthering confusion about who to talk to about problems with the app.
While the official account appears to have responded to some individual requests for help with the wallet in the past few months, it hasn’t posted an original status to its page since November 3.
More questions than answers
Despite reaching out to multiple relevant government entities and startups for comment about Chivo’s issues, The Block was unable to reach any officials or companies who could clearly explain why people are reporting so many issues with the wallet.
While I was immediately able to reach a friendly agent when calling the Chivo international customer service line, they said they were unauthorized to share any information and directed me to the local El Salvador embassy. An agent at El Salvador’s consumer protection office directed me to El Salvador’s Superintendent of the Financial System. I reached out to that agency on WhatsApp and received a press contact, but didn’t receive an email back. El Salvador’s Casa Presidencial press email did not answer an inquiry, either.
The Block was further unable to find any prominent, official public warnings about the fake Chivo Twitter bots and Facebook accounts, despite all the reports about the wallet not working.
It wasn’t always like this — in fact, the government used to be a lot more communicative about Chivo. In the early days, Bukele not only acknowledged Chivo’s issues but even played the role of IT support as he attentively updated his Twitter followers, which now total 3.4 million.
On September 8, Bukele told his followers that Chivo had completed a maintenance process leading to a few hours of downtime, and even encouraged people experiencing ongoing issues to post them in the comments of his thread and to fill out this form. A few days later, Bukele tweeted that 95% of the problems with Chivo had been fixed, and that the app would be functioning at 100% in the next few days.
The only official social media activity recently about the wallet has been the announcement that a new company is involved with Chivo — Los Angeles-based digital identity provider, Netki. Bukele shared a CoinTelegraph article that quoted a January 19 press release: “Through the use of Netki’s flagship KYC/AML product, OnboardID, the Salvadoran government was able to onboard over four million users within 45 days onto its Chivo Wallet, while safeguarding the wallet from attempted airdrop fraud.”
Dawn Newton, Netki founder and COO, told The Block on January 26 that it began working with Chivo “recently” and that its technology is present in all versions of the Chivo app. “However, we were not part of the initial application,” she said.
“We have read the public reports of issues that arose before we were fully engaged with the project,” Newton said, in response to a question about the blocked accounts and unauthorized use of credentials. “Any questions regarding this should be directed to the Chivo team. Our tools are purpose-built to address these kinds of issues.” Newton also clarified that Netki does not control blocking users’ wallets.
El Faro also pointed out on December 17 that a New York-based company called AlphaPoint has posted several types of engineering positions on a web page with the headline: “Build Bitcoin City: We’re Hiring in Central America.”
The website reads: “AlphaPoint is thrilled to announce our involvement with the Government of El Salvador and the Chivo platform – the first ever national cryptocurrency wallet. We are actively looking to fill several positions that will work on the ground with our team, the El Salvadorian government, and various partners on this world-changing technology.”
Other major companies who have publicly stated involvement with the Chivo app did not provide any clear answers about why the wallet has been experiencing so many issues.
Athena Bitcoin, the firm that developed key technology behind the Chivo wallet app and also owns and operates the country’s 200 Chivo-branded ATMs, did not respond to a December 20 inquiry about these Chivo issues. Athena recently said it plans to package the concept behind Chivo into a product that other governments and institutions could use.
However, an Athena spokesperson replied to a January 26 inquiry, directing questions to the company mentioned in Chivo’s terms and conditions, Chivo S.A. de C.V. “Chivo SA fully controls the usage, technical direction, and management of the Chivo wallet and handles support of all related issues,” they said. “It’s probably best that you connect [with] Chivo SA for insights therein.”
Not much is known about Chivo S.A., although the local media outlet El Faro has reported it is a private entity that owns the Chivo app.
Latin America-focused crypto exchange Bitso, which previously told The Block that it is responsible for “custody services providing storage and security services for the Chivo wallet, as well as exchange services,” did not respond to questions about reported Chivo issues including unauthorized transactions and problems transferring to other wallets.
“I’ve discussed with the Bitso team and since they are not a front-end technology provider for the Chivo Wallet, they are unable to comment at this time,” a spokesperson for Bitso told The Block on December 23.
Buenos Aires-based Koibanx, which has told The Block it is responsible for Chivo’s Lightning Network implementation, did not respond by press time.
BitGo, which Forbes has reported is Chivo’s hot wallet provider, also did not respond to a request for comment.
For now, Chivo still appears to be inconsistent, with several outstanding issues. To be fair, it’s not the first financial app on the market to have glitches, and won’t be the last. But the lack of prompt resolutions continues to be a concern — especially for those who cannot access their balances in the app.
Some of the Salvadorans I spoke with said they would keep trying to get in touch with Chivo customer service representatives, while others have given up trying to resolve their issues. Some have moved on to more direct action: a group living in the US recently started a Chivo boycott, although its Twitter following is still small.
And many are still taking to social media to shout into the void. “Mr. President, let’s start from the beginning,” Twitter user Rudy Parada posted in early January. “The Chivo Wallet needs fixing; there are so many people complaining about it, and nobody helps. Come on!”
Editor’s note: Many of the Twitter posts and quotes featured in this article have been translated from Spanish.
Want to read more long-form articles from The Block? For access to more daily in-depth news features such as this one, sign up for The Block’s News Plus membership.
© 2022 The Block Crypto, Inc. All Rights Reserved. This article is provided for informational purposes only. It is not offered or intended to be used as legal, tax, investment, financial, or other advice.